Flash News

Bota

Why is the presence of European troops in Ukraine impossible?

Why is the presence of European troops in Ukraine impossible?

The inauguration of the new US president, Donald Trump, could mark the beginning of a new Washington policy towards Ukraine, with pledges of commitment to a peace agreement or ceasefire and a clearly expressed desire for US withdrawal.

This has prompted European leaders to discuss previously unimaginable options for ensuring Ukraine's security after the war, without US involvement.

At the top of the list is French President Emmanuel Macron's suggestion to deploy European military forces in Ukraine, if a deal is reached.

This proposal, first put forward nearly a year ago, received new impetus after Trump's victory in the US presidential election. Last month, Italian Defense Minister Guido Crosetto said Rome would be willing to join such a mission, while his German counterpart, Boris Pistorius, said Berlin was "preparing" and "considering scenarios."

But these two examples highlight the major obstacles to achieving such a mission.

Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said such discussions are premature.

Given the occupation of the Soviet Union — including Ukraine — by Nazi Germany during World War II, it is also difficult to imagine German forces being deployed in Ukraine.

The European Union's foreign affairs chief, Kaja Kallas, said that as long as Russia is bombing Ukraine, "we have nothing to discuss."

Of course, she meant “we have nothing to discuss publicly.” But her comment highlights another factor that could make a European military role impossible: Russian President Vladimir Putin.

“I think there is absolutely no indication that Putin is interested in negotiations at this point,” said Ian Bond, deputy director of the Center for European Reform. “You know, Putin thinks he’s winning.”

Bond is not alone in this assessment.

But Trump seems to disagree, having declared at a Jan. 7 press conference at Mar-a-Lago that he believed he could reach a deal within six months. But, still, there is no sign that Putin would accept a European force.

Nicu Popescu, from the European Council on Foreign Relations, sees another difficulty. As a permanent member of the UN Security Council, Moscow could block any peacekeeping mission.

"The problem with traditional peacekeeping missions is that they depend on UN decisions, which means that Russia can veto or end the mission at any moment. Such a mission would not be limited to Western countries, but would also include troops from other parts of the world," he said.

Popescu, who was Moldova's Foreign Minister in 2021-2024, said that European leaders are not discussing peacekeeping troops.

"What is being discussed is a military presence to prevent another war. That means troops, not lightly armed peacekeeping forces, but troops equipped with anti-aircraft capabilities, for cybersecurity, to protect cities like Odessa and Kiev," he said.

Popescu admits that this is a "difficult task" for European armies.

Britain and France have the most powerful armies in Europe, but they are overstretched.

In Britain, the military has been largely focused on counter-terrorism and counter-insurgency operations since the September 11, 2001 attacks on the US. It has undergone cuts in resources over the past decade and a recent parliamentary report said Britain was “unprepared” to deal with the Russian threat.

In July, Prime Minister Keir Starmer announced that the defence strategy would be reviewed, stating that Britain's armed forces were "weakened".

The French military has more personnel than the British, but is also overstretched by long combat deployments in Africa. French experts have expressed doubts about the French military's ability to handle a more intense conflict, such as the one in Ukraine.

“We only have six long-range missile launchers, we have no real means to combat drones,” Leo Peria Peigne, of the French Institute for International Relations, noted in November.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has said that security guarantees for Kiev to end Russia's war would be effective only if they were provided by the United States. Some supporters of the idea of ​​a European military presence say this would only be possible with U.S. help in areas such as planning, logistics and intelligence./ REL

Latest news