
US bombs in Germany/DW: Trump's distancing from Europe is weakening common nuclear defense
French President Emmanuel Macron had been waiting for a positive response from Berlin for a long time. He had repeatedly offered to hold talks between Germany and France on nuclear defense, based on French atomic weapons. So far, these were just empty words.
But the situation is changing: CDU leader Friedrich Merz, the likely next German chancellor, is ready for dialogue. With Donald Trump in the White House, it could be that the US will no longer offer nuclear protection as it has done so far. Merz wants to talk to the two nuclear powers, France and Great Britain, about this issue. Paris has opened its doors.
American bombs in Germany
For decades, Germany has been under the US nuclear shield. It is said that up to 20 atomic bombs are located in Germany, but the code for their use is only in the hands of the US president. For its part, the Bundeswehr provides fighter jets that will transport them if necessary. NATO calls this joint organization "nuclear participation", in which other European countries also participate.
Security experts do not expect the US to give up its nuclear weapons in the near future. "I do not think it is a near-term scenario, because NATO and nuclear participation are of great strategic importance to the US for various reasons," says Sascha Hach, an expert on European security and arms control at the Frankfurt Institute for Peace Studies, PRIF. "But it cannot be ruled out." One of the US's strategic advantages is the ability to respond to Russian aggression in Europe.
Germany has no right to have nuclear weapons
Even if the American bombs remain in Europe, the doubts that Donald Trump is sowing about the American promise to NATO are harmful and undermine the credibility of the nuclear threat. Germany, which has always relied on the US, now intends to reorient its security policy. The Bundeswehr will have to arm itself faster than planned. There is also debate about the nuclear shield: How valuable is it in these circumstances against Russia's vast nuclear arsenal of more than 5,500 nuclear warheads?
Germany itself is not allowed to have nuclear weapons. This was stipulated in the "Two Plus Four Agreement" of German reunification.
In Europe, only Great Britain and France have nuclear weapons, and within the EU, only France. Close cooperation seems the best way forward. But there are also limitations: British nuclear forces are closely linked to American ones and, in the event of a conflict, are made available to NATO. The situation is different in France, which attaches great importance to the independence of its nuclear armed forces. They are not dependent on NATO's joint command structures.
France possesses, according to some estimates, 290 nuclear warheads that can be commanded by nuclear submarines or Rafale fighter jets. The nuclear armed forces must protect the country's "vital interests", according to French doctrine. According to the French interpretation, they also strengthen the security of Europe by making it difficult for potential enemies to calculate.
What would cooperation in this regard look like?
In Paris, it is said that an intensive dialogue must first be held. Information on the operational and strategic planning of nuclear weapons is extremely important. France has decades of experience in this area, which Germany does not have.
What is being considered are joint training of French and German fighter aircraft, says French security expert Camille Grand from the European Council on Foreign Relations. This could also include the accession of Rafale aircraft to Germany. There is no talk, as was rumored in the media, of stationing French nuclear fighter aircraft or other nuclear infrastructure in Germany.
Command remains with the French president.
France does not discuss the nuclear participation in its atomic weapons, as NATO does. Therefore, for expert Grand, "it is a mistake to think that French nuclear guarantees compensate for American nuclear guarantees," he told DW.
The French government has made it clear: It will not relinquish the decision to use nuclear weapons. "No matter what happens, the decision has been and will remain in the hands of the President of the Republic, the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces," the French president said in a speech to the nation in March.
What can Europe do?
Not only the French nuclear forces, but also the British ones are very much oriented towards national defense. Great Britain is the only nuclear-armed country that has only a certain type of nuclear weapon. The country's nuclear threat is based entirely on naval defense, four nuclear submarines stationed on the west coast of Scotland.
This limits the possibility that these weapons will be put to use in the near future for a European nuclear defense. What could be considered is an intensified strategic dialogue, but also "a political declaration that the French and British nuclear arsenals could also be used to defend European territory if necessary," expert Sascha Hach tells DW. "But I don't think it's realistic that the armed forces in France and Great Britain will develop in such a way that they are also suitable for European defense."
The number of bombs doesn't matter.
Friedrich Merz in Germany also emphasizes that it is not a question of replacing US nuclear weapons, but rather of supplementing them. The US is seen as irreplaceable in NATO not only because of its nuclear arsenal, but also because of other special capabilities of these weapons. This includes direct contact with Russian command centers and warning systems for ballistic missiles. These help to avoid unintended escalations - "If we in Europe are currently discussing how to do without the US, we are focusing on whether we have enough bombs," Hach emphasizes. This forgets that other security mechanisms could be lost without the US, such as direct contact with the adversary. "Here I would say that it is in Europe's interest to set up similar structures and mechanisms over which we have control."/DW
Latest news



How did LaCivita change the DP campaign? Berisha: He studied the opponent
2025-05-08 22:49:51

David defeats Goliath
2025-05-08 22:15:50

Journalist: There are SPAK infiltrators in party headquarters
2025-05-08 21:55:15
Who is the new Pope?
2025-05-08 21:48:13
Berisha finally reveals when he will retire from politics
2025-05-08 21:33:46


LaCivita in Lezha: Albanians will fire Edi Rama from his job
2025-05-08 21:11:20


Berisha: LaCivita chose us because he believes in Reagan's program
2025-05-08 20:48:40
He rejected America to serve Pogradec, Genti Çela tells about life in "Elevate"
2025-05-08 20:26:28




Pope Leo XIV greets the faithful for the first time in St. Peter's Square
2025-05-08 19:29:33




Photo session with LaCivitta in Tirana: For Great Albania
2025-05-08 18:40:18
Source: DASH decision a personal victory for Berisha
2025-05-08 18:30:10
Take off those crazy glasses and see where you've taken him?
2025-05-08 18:02:47
LDK files criminal charges against members of the incumbent Government
2025-05-08 18:02:00







BIRN analysis: Tirana, the determining district for the future majority
2025-05-08 16:04:03




Chris LaCivita's contract with the DP, Berisha: 100% correct and clean
2025-05-08 15:11:11

"These are the peak days", Berisha reveals when he will travel to the USA
2025-05-08 14:45:25


Endless boxes with filled-in ballots, DP demands separation of votes from Greece
2025-05-08 14:11:12


Photo/ Who are the 3 associates of Talo Çela arrested in Dubai?
2025-05-08 13:37:09

Hetimi për krimet zgjedhore, Altin Dumani zbarkon në Prokurorinë e Shkodrës
2025-05-08 13:06:21
DASH paves the way for Berisha, Alizoti: Great news on the eve of Great Albania!
2025-05-08 13:03:48

"Freedom works", DP welcomes the US position
2025-05-08 12:48:07

Black smoke rises from the Sistine Chapel, the Vatican still without a Pope
2025-05-08 12:26:18





Davide Pecorrelli extradited to Albania
2025-05-08 11:29:04
'May 11, Albania will react', Xhaferri: Electoral criminals will pay
2025-05-08 11:21:46

Gjin Gjoni: Non Grata fell, Rama should get ready to go to McGonigal
2025-05-08 11:01:54
May 8th deadline for immigrants to vote in Greece extended by one day
2025-05-08 10:48:42
Collapse of massive chrome structure, still no trace of 29-year-old
2025-05-08 10:40:04
Vehicle bursts into flames in Paris Commune
2025-05-08 10:25:43
He gave land to his father and cousin, Basir Çollaku denounces the SP candidate
2025-05-08 10:16:16




Electoral Crimes/ BKH agents and Police conduct checks in Shkodra
2025-05-08 09:19:13
3 associates of Talo Çela arrested in Dubai
2025-05-08 09:02:28
Mouse in the owl's claws, Chris LaCivita responds directly to Rama
2025-05-08 08:45:40
Foreign exchange, how much foreign currencies are sold and bought today
2025-05-08 08:30:38
BIRN: Organized crime, the 'invisible party' of the Durrës elections
2025-05-08 08:26:35
Horoscope, what do the stars have in store for you today?
2025-05-08 08:08:15
Cloudy and rainy, what the weather is expected to be like throughout the day
2025-05-08 07:52:13
Posta e mëngjesit/ Me 2 rreshta: Çfarë pati rëndësi dje në Shqipëri
2025-05-08 07:40:16


Rama attacks Bardhi: Fier cannot be represented by the world's gas
2025-05-07 22:36:22



EU calls on Israel to lift humanitarian blockade in Gaza
2025-05-07 21:42:34
"Russia is "asking for a lot"! Vance calls for direct Moscow-Kiev talks
2025-05-07 21:20:16





Bank of Albania sets limits on home loans, Sejko: The maximum will be 85%
2025-05-07 20:16:10


EP calls for immediate lifting of measures against Kosovo
2025-05-07 19:39:58